Skip to content

From Language Learning to Hallucination: How AI Hallucinations Affect Decision-Making?

Share
From Language Learning to Hallucination: How AI Hallucinations Affect Decision-Making?

From Language Learning to Hallucination: How AI Hallucinations Affect Decision-Making?

  • Where do we start this time?

In the previous article we discussed teaching the “language” of AI: how to give it clearer inputs, better context and more specific instructions.

But even if we do that well, an important question remains:

  • What if the model gives us an answer that looks correct… but isn’t?

This brings us to what is known as hallucination

(Hallucination).

I do not want to talk about it this time solely as a technical problem.

What matters most to me is another question:

When does a small hallucination on an AI screen become a real decision inside an organization?

Because the problem is not that the model might err.

The problem starts when its error moves from the conversation into the workflow.

  • Hallucination becomes dangerous when someone relies on it

Suppose I am reviewing a technical case and ask the AI to identify the clause that supports a rejection.

The model gives me:

Clause number.

Standard name.

And an explanation that seems logical.

I read the answer.

It matches what I originally thought.

So I copy it into the report.

From here the “conversation with AI” ends.

And the decision cycle begins.

The error is now inside an official document.

Another reviewer reads the report and sees a clear reference.

A manager approves.

A NCR is issued.

The supplier starts rework.

Only later does someone open the code and discover that the clause does not say what we wrote.

What happened here?

The hallucination did not make the decision itself.

But it supplied the decision with a false justification.

In my view that is the most important link between hallucination and decision.

  • Decisions are not always built on a single piece of information

Sometimes we imagine the error must be large to change a decision.

Reality is different.

A wrong piece of information can be very small:

Clause number.

Revision.

Tolerance value.

Test date.

Document status.

Supplier name.

Or even a single word in a long summary.

But if that information falls at the point where the decision passes, its impact is far greater than its size.

For example:

If the AI says the maximum acceptable is 3 mm while the reference says 5 mm, the numerical difference is small.

Yet the resulting decision may be:

Reject instead of Accept.

NCR instead of Conformance.

Repair instead of Release.

Cost instead of No cost.

The error is small in the data… but large in the decision.

  • Let’s take another example: a product release decision

Imagine you have dozens of documents before a Product Release:

Inspection reports.

Material certificates.

Test reports.

NCRs.

Punch lists.

Various approvals.

AI is used to summarize the status for management.

It produces a summary that says:

"All inspection reports are complete, and there are no open non-conformances affecting release."

The summary looks clear.

صورة مولّدة بالذكاء الاصطناعي · AI Gossips

The manager does not have time to open fifty files.

He relies on the summary.

And issues the decision:

"Release."

Later it turns out there is an open NCR that was not part of the documents analyzed, or was summarized in a way that hid its significance.

Here the model may not have invented an entire fact.

Perhaps the problem is that it built a result on incomplete data.

But for the decision-maker, the outcome is the same:

A seemingly correct decision built on an incomplete picture.

That type of risk is no less important than traditional hallucination.

  • Hallucination may shift priority… not just truth

Let’s step out of QA/QC for a moment.

Imagine a department that receives a thousand customer complaints.

It asks the AI to identify the five most important issues that merit management intervention.

The model ranks the issues.

Management starts with the top five.

But what if the model places a recurring, serious complaint at rank seven because its wording varies across customers and it does not recognise it as a single pattern?

It did not provide a “false” piece of information in the usual sense.

Yet it influenced the decision through the “priority ordering.”

Here the impact of hallucination or misunderstanding is more subtle.

AI does not need to tell you:

"Make this decision."

It is enough that it says:

"This is more important than that."

And you will usually start with what it placed at the top.

  • There are four stages where an error becomes a decision

I now see the issue as four simple stages:

1, Stage one: the model generates a piece of information or inference.

It may be correct or incorrect.

2, Stage two: a human trusts the output.

Perhaps because the language is convincing.

Or because the result matches expectations.

Or because there is no time for review.

3, Stage three: the output enters the system.

Report.

Management presentation.

NCR.

Supplier evaluation.

Risk register.

Recommendation.

4, Stage four: a person makes a decision based on it.

Accept.

Reject.

Purchase.

Stop.

Release.

Escalate.

Or set a priority.

At that point, the hallucination is no longer an “AI error.”

It has become an input to an organizational decision.

  • And a more dangerous thing appears: the decision may look entirely human

Imagine you reviewed a document prepared by AI.

You edited a few words.

Then you signed it.

On paper, the decision is human.

But what if the core idea, the reference, the risk ranking, or the recommendation all came from the model?

Is a human signature enough to call the decision truly human?

In my view: not always.

If a person only checks the final form while AI gathered, linked, ordered the information and suggested the outcome, the model’s real influence is far greater than the signature suggests.

That explains why I said in the second article that the most dangerous future decision might be a paper-based human decision…

…but AI drew the entire path to it.

صورة مولّدة بالذكاء الاصطناعي · AI Gossips
  • The most dangerous hallucination is the one that confirms our view

A human factor makes the problem larger.

It is called “confirmation bias.”

If I already believe a supplier is weak, and the AI gives me an analysis saying the supplier’s performance is poor, I am likely to accept the result.

If I already think a case should be rejected, and the AI supplies a clause that supports rejection, I will be less inclined to question it.

Here a dangerous convergence of two errors occurs:

Hallucination from the model.

And confirmation bias from the human.

The model gives me what looks like evidence.

And I accept it because I was looking for that evidence in the first place.

Therefore, sometimes I should be more skeptical when the AI gives me exactly what I wanted to hear.

  • Good phrasing gives error authority

The model might say:

According to Clause 17.4…

Then provide a tidy interpretation.

The sentence alone creates a sense of a confirmed reference.

But form does not prove truth.

Here we must separate:

Language fluency

and

information reliability.

The text may be excellent.

The formatting may be excellent.

The apparent logic may be excellent.

But the source is missing.

Or the version is wrong.

Or the inference is incorrect.

Hence I repeat a simple rule:

The more important the decision, the less you should rely on the shape of the answer and the more you should rely on its source.

  • Can a wrong decision be costly even if we discover it later?

Absolutely.

Imagine a NCR issued based on an incorrect reference.

Two days later we discover the error.

We might say:

We correct it and that’s that.

But in those two days the following may have happened:

The supplier stopped work.

Repair began.

An extra team was booked.

Shipment was delayed.

An escalation with the customer occurred.

Trust between parties was damaged.

Even if we later fix the error, “the impact of the decision may already have occurred.”

This shows verification should not come after the decision.

It must happen “before information turns into action.”

  • What about less obvious decisions?

Not every decision is Accept or Reject.

There are quieter decisions:

Which supplier do we review first?

Which project needs an audit?

Which complaint do we escalate?

Which employee needs training?

Which risk do we place at the top of the list?

If AI is used to classify or rank these items, it influences the decision even without pressing any button.

Thus I see hallucination should not be understood only as “inventing information.”

It can also be:

A weak inference.

An inaccurate classification.

A wrong link between two cases.

Or over-confidence in a non-existent pattern.

The end result is the same:

"The wrong supplier gets priority."

صورة مولّدة بالذكاء الاصطناعي · AI Gossips

"The real problem is delayed."

"And the decision moves in a unsuitable direction."

  • When should the decision stop and we verify?

For me, there is a clear point:

If an AI output will change what we actually do, the matter has moved from “useful information” to “information that influences a decision.”

That is where verification is raised.

Especially if the information includes:

Clause number.

A numeric value.

Requirement.

Acceptance criteria.

Revision.

NCR status.

A recommendation to accept or reject.

Risk rating.

Or any piece of information that could lead to cost, delay, safety, liability, or impact on another party.

In these cases, the question is not:

Does the answer look correct?

The question is:

Do I have independent evidence to confirm it before I build a decision on it?

  • Research is one thing… proof is another.

I use AI a lot to get to the information faster.

That is a very powerful use.

I can say:

Help me identify where to look for the requirement related to this case.

Or:

Which sections should I review in this specification?

Here AI helps me search.

But when I reach the decision, I want the source itself.

There is a big difference between:

"AI pointed me to the path."

and:

"AI became the evidence."

The former I see as smart use.

The latter depends entirely on the level of risk and context, and we should not automatically assume that a generated answer alone is sufficient to justify an important decision.

  • What it means for you

In the previous article the skill was:

"How to talk to AI better?"

Here the next skill is:

"How to prevent its answer from turning into a decision before it deserves that?"

I think this is the most practical point about hallucination.

Don’t stop at the question:

Did the model err?

Ask:

"Where will this information go once it is written?"

Will it stay in the conversation?

Or will it enter a report?

Will it appear in a meeting?

Will a manager build a recommendation on it?

Will it trigger a repair?

Will a supplier be rejected?

Will a product be released?

The closer the information gets to action, the higher the price of error.

Therefore the most dangerous hallucination is not necessarily the biggest false piece of information AI produces.

It may be a very short sentence…

But placed in the right spot within the workflow.

Then a person believes it.

Then another person documents it.

Then a decision is issued based on it.

"And here hallucination shifts from an AI problem… to a real-world problem."


About the author: Khalid Saleh, inspection and quality control consultant and metallurgical engineer, with over twenty years of experience in asset safety, inspection and corrosion control in the energy and industrial sectors, working from Riyadh to automate inspection workflows with artificial intelligence.

Don't miss the next story

Subscribe for updates